Clustering Educational Digital Library Usage Data: A Comparison of Latent Class Analysis and K-Means Algorithms
نویسنده
چکیده
This article examines clustering as an educational data mining method. In particular, two clustering algorithms, the widely used K-means and the model-based Latent Class Analysis, are compared, using usage data from an educational digital library service, the Instructional Architect (IA.usu.edu). Using a multi-faceted approach and multiple data sources, three types of comparisons of resulting clusters are presented: 1) Davies-Bouldin indices, 2) clustering results validated with user profile data, and 3) cluster evolution. Latent Class Analysis is superior to K-means on all three comparisons. In particular, LCA is more immune to the variance of feature variables, and clustering results turn out well with minimal data transformation. Our research results also show that LCA perform better than K-means in terms of providing the most useful educational interpretation for this dataset.
منابع مشابه
A Hybrid Data Clustering Algorithm Using Modified Krill Herd Algorithm and K-MEANS
Data clustering is the process of partitioning a set of data objects into meaning clusters or groups. Due to the vast usage of clustering algorithms in many fields, a lot of research is still going on to find the best and efficient clustering algorithm. K-means is simple and easy to implement, but it suffers from initialization of cluster center and hence trapped in local optimum. In this paper...
متن کاملTeaching Analytics: A Clustering and Triangulation Study of Digital Library User Data
Teachers and students increasingly enjoy unprecedented access to abundant web resources and digital libraries to enhance and enrich their classroom experiences. However, due to the distributed nature of such systems, conventional educational research methods, such as surveys and observations, provide only limited snapshots. In addition, educational data mining, as an emergent research approach,...
متن کاملApplying Web Usage Mining to an Educational Digital Library Service
This case study in educational data mining (EDM) describes the motivation, methods, results, and best practices used while studying the usage data from users of a web-based tool, the Instructional Architect (IA.usu.edu). Our focus is twofold: (a) to highlight lessons learned for those new to data mining and (b) to introduce the analysis techniques of latent class modeling as an analysis tool. T...
متن کاملUnderstanding Teacher Users of a Digital Library Service: A Clustering Approach
This article describes the Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining (KDD) process and its application in the field of educational data mining (EDM) in the context of a digital library service called the Instructional Architect (IA.usu.edu). In particular, the study reported in this article investigated a certain type of data mining problem, clustering, and used a statistical model, latent class anal...
متن کاملAssessment of the Performance of Clustering Algorithms in the Extraction of Similar Trajectories
In recent years, the tremendous and increasing growth of spatial trajectory data and the necessity of processing and extraction of useful information and meaningful patterns have led to the fact that many researchers have been attracted to the field of spatio-temporal trajectory clustering. The process and analysis of these trajectories have resulted in the extraction of useful information whic...
متن کامل